We ask the popular question: Is Hong Kong a Better Financial Hub Than Singapore? For decades, Hong Kong and Singapore have been fierce rivals as global financial hubs, each boasting unique advantages that make them attractive to businesses, investors, and financial institutions. While both cities share similarities—such as low tax regimes, strong regulatory frameworks, and strategic locations in Asia—there are key differences that influence their competitiveness as financial hubs.
Infrastructure and Efficiency
Both cities boast world-class infrastructure, excellent connectivity, and efficient public transport systems. Hong Kong has historically been a top choice for multinational corporations due to its free-market policies and global business links.
However, Singapore has gained traction with its smart city initiatives, sustainable urban planning, and tax incentives for multinational firms.
Regulatory and Business Environment
Hong Kong has historically been known for its free economic policies, with a legal system rooted in British common law, which investors find familiar and reliable. The Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) oversees a free-market approach, ensuring a high degree of financial freedom. However, increasing regulatory influence from mainland China has raised concerns among foreign investors regarding transparency and autonomy.
Singapore, on the other hand, is often regarded as having a more predictable and stable regulatory environment. The Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) enforces stringent but clear regulations, maintaining a reputation for transparency and efficiency. The city-state is also a leader in financial innovation, particularly in fintech and digital banking, which has attracted global firms seeking a secure and progressive business environment.
Market Access and Connectivity
Hong Kong serves as the primary gateway to China, providing access to the world’s second-largest economy through initiatives like the Stock Connect and Bond Connect programs. This makes it an attractive base for financial institutions looking to tap into Chinese markets.
Singapore, in contrast, positions itself as a hub for Southeast Asia, providing access to fast-growing economies like Indonesia, Vietnam, and Malaysia. Its financial sector has benefited from strong regional trade agreements and a diversified economic base beyond finance, including logistics and technology.
Financial Market Strength
Hong Kong has traditionally been the gateway to China’s economy, with many Chinese firms choosing to list in Hong Kong due to its proximity to mainland China. It remains a dominant force in global finance due to its deep capital markets and stock exchange, which is among the world’s top in terms of IPO fundraising. The Hong Kong Stock Exchange (HKEX) is one of the largest in the world, attracting numerous Chinese firms seeking international capital.
Singapore, while not as strong in IPO fundraising, has positioned itself as a key hub for asset management, private banking, and wealth management. Its reputation as a safe and politically stable jurisdiction makes it an attractive location for high-net-worth individuals looking to manage their assets. The Singapore Exchange (SGX) is smaller than HKEX but remains competitive in derivatives and real estate investment trusts (REITs). Moreover, Singapore has positioned itself as a regional hub for cryptocurrency and digital finance.
Talent and Workforce
Hong Kong has traditionally been a magnet for top-tier financial professionals with a longer history as a financial hub. It is more integrated with Mainland China’s wealth market. Many wealth managers specialise in handling high-net-worth (HNW) and ultra-high-net-worth (UHNW) Chinese clients, making them highly skilled in navigating China’s financial landscape. Wealth managers tend to focus on aggressive growth strategies, equities, IPOs, and alternative investments such as private equity and hedge funds. However, political uncertainties and strict pandemic-related policies have led to an exodus of expatriates and skilled workers. This has raised concerns about its ability to retain a competitive edge in the long run.
While slightly newer in wealth management compared to Hong Kong, Singapore has taken a proactive approach to attracting global talent through favorable immigration policies and business-friendly regulations. The city-state consistently ranks highly in global talent competitiveness. In Singapore, there is more emphasis on wealth preservation, ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investments, and structured wealth solutions like trust and estate planning. Its market is more diversified, with wealth managers handling assets from ASEAN, Europe, India, and the Middle East. Therefore, Singapore wealth managers often have an edge in international compliance, tax efficiency, and family office structuring.
Tax and Cost of Living
Both cities offer attractive tax regimes. Hong Kong has a simple tax system with a corporate tax rate capped at 16.5% and no capital gains tax. Singapore offers a slightly higher corporate tax rate of 17% but provides various incentives and tax reliefs to businesses, making it highly competitive. Singapore also has no capital gains tax.
However, the cost of living in both cities is high, with housing being a major concern. Singapore has managed to maintain a more stable property market, whereas Hong Kong continues to face affordability challenges, with some of the world’s most expensive real estate prices.
Political and Geopolitical Stability
Political stability is a growing differentiator between the two cities. Singapore is widely regarded as one of the most politically stable countries in the world, with clear government policies and long-term strategic planning. This has contributed to strong investor confidence.
Hong Kong, on the other hand, has faced increased political uncertainty since the introduction of the National Security Law in 2020. While it remains a major financial hub, concerns over its autonomy from Beijing have led some firms to shift operations or diversify into Singapore.
Which is the Better Financial Hub?
The answer depends on business needs and risk appetite. For firms focused on Chinese markets and stock trading, Hong Kong remains the preferred choice. However, for those seeking regional diversification, regulatory stability, and a fintech-friendly environment, Singapore is increasingly seen as the better option.
While Hong Kong still holds an edge in certain areas, Singapore’s ability to attract global talent, its stable political environment, and proactive financial policies suggest that it may be the more future-proof financial hub in the long run.
For enquiries on Family Office, call/Whatsapp to +65 8766 1966 or email to info@iasg.com.sg.
